If you own an HP DeskJet 4155e, HP ENVY 6055e, DeskJet 2755e, or any of HP's current consumer inkjet printers, you use HP 67 ink cartridges. And there's one simple rule: always buy the XL version. The math isn't even close. Here's the complete breakdown — page yields, cost per page, and when HP Instant Ink makes the whole debate irrelevant.
HP 67 vs 67XL: The Numbers
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Standard black (HP 67) | 120 pages | ~$14 | $0.117/page |
|---|---|
| XL black (HP 67XL) | 240 pages | ~$20 | $0.083/page |
| Standard color (HP 67) | 100 pages | ~$18 | $0.180/page |
| XL color (HP 67XL) | 200 pages | ~$24 | $0.120/page |
| Combo pack (black + color XL) | 240 + 200 pages | ~$40 | best value |
Why XL Is Always the Right Choice
The XL cartridges cost approximately 33–40% more than standard cartridges but yield 100% more pages. That translates to a roughly 30% lower cost per page. Over a year of moderate printing (100 pages/month), switching from standard to XL saves approximately $50–$70 in ink costs. The savings compound year over year, and the convenience factor (fewer cartridge changes) is meaningful too.
To put it in concrete terms: if you're buying standard HP 67 black at $14 for 120 pages, you'll go through roughly 10 cartridges per year printing 100 pages/month — $140 in ink. With XL at $20 for 240 pages, you need only 5 cartridges per year — $100 in ink. That's $40 saved on just the black cartridge. Add color savings and you're easily saving $60–$80 per year.
Combo Packs: The Best Value
HP sells combo packs containing both the black and color XL cartridges for around $40. This is the best way to buy HP 67 ink — you save versus buying each cartridge separately, and you get both at once. Check Amazon for current pricing on combo packs, as they occasionally go on sale during Prime Day and other events.
Compatible Printers
HP 67 and 67XL cartridges work with HP's current consumer inkjet lineup:
- HP ENVY 6055e / 6455e — wireless all-in-ones
- HP DeskJet 2755e / 4155e — budget all-in-ones
- HP DeskJet Plus 4155 — older model, same cartridge
- HP ENVY Pro 6455 — previous generation
Both standard and XL cartridges are interchangeable — any HP 67-compatible printer accepts either size. You don't need to do anything special to use XL cartridges; they install identically.
HP Instant Ink: A Third Option
If you own an HP+ enrolled printer, HP Instant Ink may be the best value of all. For $5.99/month (50 pages) or $9.99/month (100 pages), HP ships you ink automatically before you run out. At the 50-page tier, that works out to $0.12/page — which is cheaper than retail HP 67 standard cartridges and comparable to XL pricing. The advantage is no upfront cartridge costs and no surprise ink-outs. The downside: if you cancel the subscription, the Instant Ink cartridges stop working.
Third-Party / Compatible HP 67 Cartridges
If your printer is NOT enrolled in HP+, compatible third-party HP 67 cartridges are available on Amazon for $8–$15 per pack. These can save 50–70% vs genuine HP cartridges. Quality varies by brand — see our compatible HP ink cartridge guide for recommended brands and risks. If your printer IS enrolled in HP+, it will reject non-HP cartridges entirely.
Pros
- XL yields 100% more pages for ~33% more cost
- Combo packs offer additional savings
- Consistent genuine HP print quality
- Wide compatibility across current HP models
Cons
- Standard yields are very low (120 black / 100 color)
- Even XL yields are modest vs laser toner
- HP+ printers reject third-party alternatives
- Cost per page is high vs EcoTank
Our Verdict: ALWAYS BUY XL
There's no reason to buy standard HP 67 cartridges. XL costs 33% more but prints 100% more pages. Buy the combo pack for the best value. Consider HP Instant Ink if you print consistently.
Find HP 67 XL on Amazon →Frequently Asked Questions
How many pages does HP 67XL black print?
The HP 67XL black cartridge yields approximately 240 pages based on HP's ISO-rated standard. Actual yield varies with content coverage — heavy graphics or photos will reduce the page count.
Can I use HP 67XL in any HP 67 printer?
Yes. HP 67 and 67XL are interchangeable in all compatible printers. The XL cartridge simply holds more ink. No special settings or adapters are needed.
Is HP Instant Ink cheaper than buying HP 67XL?
It depends on your volume. At $5.99/month for 50 pages, Instant Ink costs $0.12/page — roughly comparable to HP 67XL. At $9.99/month for 100 pages, it drops to $0.10/page — cheaper than XL. The key advantage is convenience and no surprise costs.
Can I use third-party HP 67 cartridges?
Only if your printer is NOT enrolled in HP+. HP+ printers reject non-HP cartridges. Non-HP+ printers can use compatible third-party cartridges, which cost 50-70% less. Quality varies by brand — see our compatible ink guide.
About this review: PrinterStores.com is reader-supported. Affiliate links on this page may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Our rankings are never influenced by manufacturers or advertisers. All prices were verified at time of publication — check Amazon for current pricing.